Toilet Paper Hanging: The Buyer Decides

We’ve posted a lot about hanging the toilet paper recently. To recap:

• Hanging the Toilet Paper: In Defense of Under
• Toilet Paper Hanging Battle
• Recessed TP Dispensers: Sometimes “Under” Sucks

Still, the case is hardly closed. In a recent comment, Mollie writes the following:

Um. Over is the correct way. Especially when someone else is living in your house, free of charge, and every single time they replace the roll, it’s under, when I, every single time, switch it. TAKE A HINT!

While I can’t agree with her unequivocal endorsement of Over, she makes a good point. Perhaps the person who actually goes to the trouble of purchasing the toilet paper should be the one who gets to decide how to hang it?